anderson's Puzzle Blog

2017 Mystery Hunt recap

leave a comment »

The MIT Mystery Hunt happened two weekends two months ago, so here’s a (very belated) recap. It was my 9th hunt, and 4th with ✈✈✈ Galactic Trendsetters ✈✈✈.


I flew into MIT on Wednesday, two days before the hunt. It turned out that we waited until the day before to get snacks, and we didn’t have access to a car on Thursday, so we decided to just buy everything at Shaw’s/Star Market. Unfortunately, we also didn’t have access to shopping carts, but luckily Max had like 4 empty suitcases lying around his room so we planned to use those. Anyways, it was pretty funny having 8 people walking into Shaw’s, buying 400 dollars worth of snacks and drinks, and trying to stuff everything into suitcases. Overall, it turned out surprisingly well because exactly the right number of people came to carry things back to hall, and the snack choice was also fine (as my team knows, my only complaint is that we didn’t have any HK Anderson peanut butter pretzels, which are far and away the best snack in existence).

I planned to sleep from 2 to 10 AM, but I woke up at 3 or so and couldn’t fall back asleep, so I paced around, read Facebook, read poetry, etc. Eventually I think I fell asleep around 7, so although I only got ~4 hours sleep total, this was 4 hours more than I got last year, which is an improvement.


On Friday morning, a bunch of us head over to our rooms to move tables around and set up the food. Somehow, we got 3 moderate-sized rooms this year, which is amazing compared to previous years (last year we had 1 large room whose windows didn’t open, which eventually got pretty awful). The windows also almost didn’t open this year, but then Theo figured out how to do it (you needed to push down before you could pull up), which boded well in terms of puzzle-solving! We go to Flour as usual, and head to the kickoff. The skit was great, and basically everyone was excited.

Early on, I spent a large amount of time adding puzzles to our google spreadsheet system instead of solving because I set it up the night before and couldn’t figure out how to give other people access. Thankfully, Jakob figured out how protected ranges worked by Friday evening, so I wasn’t doing it the entire hunt.

SPOILER WARNING: I’ll talk a little about the puzzles I worked on now, so feel free to skip to the bottom if you want to avoid spoilers. Also feel free to skip to the bottom if you don’t care about specific puzzles; this will probably be long and rambling.

I started by working on Four-Part Harmony. We were quite puzzled for a few minutes before someone decided to read the first word of each line, and then I think it was solved within 5 minutes.

Next, I joined some people who were doing Locked In and basically watched it get solved. This was a very fun puzzle, so I suggest that you try it out if you haven’t seen it.

At this point we’d unlocked the first quest, so Lucy, Nathan, and I decided to help out on Star Search. People were mostly done with song identification by then and were trying to figure out what to do with, well, all of the data. We were stuck for maybe 30 minutes-1 hour, when I had my favorite aha moment of the hunt. I was thinking of the astrology symbols, and I said something like “Hmm, aren’t there also 88 constellations, like 88 keys on a piano? Maybe we should see if there’s a canonical ordering or something….awww it doesn’t look like it.” Lucy and I then looked at the Aries keyboard, and we were like “Hmmm Aries is pretty early in the alphabet and it’s on the 7th key in this keyboard, I wonder what’s the position of Aries in the alphabetized list of constellations?” Then we looked it up, discovered it was also 7, went “OHHHH NOOOOOOOOO,” and the puzzle was solved fairly soon afterwards (though we had some issues due to being bad at counting).

Some people were stuck on Heirplay, so we looked at that next. Again, we were stuck for quite a bit, and for a long time the only thing we liked was CRAM->CREAM in the second group. We tried lots of incorrect things like transforming each group in a different way, but at some point, Patrick saved the day when he turned CAT+BAND into BATDANCE and saw that it was a Prince song. Then, we all understood what the flavortext meant.

After that, I joined a group of people who were all looking at Basic Phrenology, which was stuck on the final step. I didn’t help at all, but I’m mentioning this puzzle because when someone finally figured out what to do, it was pretty amazing, and you should try it yourself/read the solution to find out what it was.

Next I worked on Repeated Punishment with Nathan, Lucy, Stephanie, and others. I think we figured out what to do immediately (Nathan remembered a 2013 Mystery Hunt puzzle that used the same source material) and it was done very quickly.

I spent the next ~2 hours working on A Beauty Cold and Austere in the second quest with Lucy, Jon, and others. The puzzle provided parametric curves which looked like public art somewhere on MIT, and each artwork corresponded to one of the statements at the bottom, from which you could extract the parameters, which converted alphanumerically to the answer. We spent way too much time failing at graphing these, because it seemed like no one had Mathematica on them (no more free licenses from high school math competitions lol). We manually transcribed some of them by hand and tried to stick them in WolframAlpha, except WolframAlpha sucks. Jon was able to plot some of the simpler ones in Sage, except we couldn’t identify any of them. Someone had a laptop which had Mathematica, except when I tried copy-pasting the first equation, it failed at graphing it. Right when everything was looking bleak, I tried another equation in Mathematica, and it actually worked and we immediately identified it as the red sculpture on the Stata lawn, which I now know is called Aesop’s Fables, II. Jon and I walked over there to find out which beam had the signature on it, and we were able to deduce that the first two letters of the answer were S and T. Then, Damien found a picture of the butterfly sculpture, so we now had ST??S??????. I guessed STRESSED OUT from Onelook, which was incorrect. We looked closer at the constraints on the parameters and saw that the third letter had to be less than the fourth letter, the eighth letter was one of {F, G, H}, and the ninth letter was one of {C, D, E, F, G}. Armed with this knowledge, we guessed ST ELSEWHERE, which was correct! Yay for Wheel of Fortune.

The third quest was open by then, so I looked at Changing Rooms with Leon, Rahul, Catherine, and others. We slowly made our way through the cryptic, which turned into a Star Battle and a LITS puzzle at the end, in an extremely impressive feat of construction (you can read the solution for details). Along with Star Search, this was my favorite puzzle of the weekend.

Next, I looked at Listicle with Leon, which was stuck after a bunch of the -ical words were identified. After trying some things for a few minutes, I read the flavortext some more, and said something like “Isn’t there that one song from Cats which lists a bunch of adjectives like this?” Luckily, that turned out to be correct, although it was unfortunate that we didn’t use the “google everything you have together” strategy earlier. I think in the next 10-20 minutes or so, 3-4 other Thespians puzzles were also finished, and the Thespians meta was soon solved.

I hadn’t done a single logic puzzle yet, so I was happy to see that Stackuro was open, and I got to work on it with Lewis and Brian S. We quickly figured out the gimmick, and the puzzle went fairly smoothly; I think we finished in about 40 minutes. There was one minor bump where we thought we had a contradiction, but then we realized that 84 could be factored in more than one valid way. Overall, I thought the solve path was very slick and I’d highly recommend this to people who like logic puzzles!

Around this time (midnight-ish), our team also solved the last two character metas and had the “Big Bad Battle” encounter, which was a lot of fun. To summarize how it worked, we had 6 people representing the party members moving themselves on a grid of wooden hexagons. Each turn, the evil sorcerer Mystereo Cantos would use some attack, to which one of the party members had to thematically respond with their special ability a.k.a. the solution to their metapuzzle. Then, a die was rolled to determine how many thematic trivia questions they had to answer in 60 seconds, and if the number was successfully met, everyone could remove the hexagon they were standing on to reveal something beneath. At any time, we could try to shout out the final answer, which was presumably on the grid underneath the hexagons.

There were two pretty great things that happened during this encounter: first, in one of the rounds, we rolled a 1 and had to answer 10 questions in a minute. We ended up barely succeeding, which was pretty exciting. Second, early on we thought that the lines underneath the hexagons were making runes, so various people were trying to look up the runic alphabet and translate them as they were getting revealed. After a decent chunk of the grid was revealed, Alejandro suggested “HIVE MIND” as the answer, which turned out to be correct. When asked how he got it, he said something like “It’s not runes, it’s just a really edgy font!”

I helped finish off location.location.location, a very cute puzzle, and then some of us tried looking at the Crafty Criminal meta now that we had 6/10 answers. Someone noticed that the second words of the answers only had letters in BLACK or WHITE, which suggested mastermind given that all the first words were 6 letters long. Lewis figured out the final answer; in the end, I think the time from start to finish was ~20 minutes which was pretty good.

It seemed like the Broken Bridge meta needed more answers, as we were at 7/16 solved, so Patrick Y and I decided to look at Altered from the Original together, which had a good amount of data gathering done but was stuck. We suspected that there might be some property that all the songs shared, and we quickly found that each of them was based on a classical piece. Now it seemed that all we had to do was index into the composers by length of the clip (the earlier group had noted that clip lengths were all integers) and sort by the pitch shifts, which seemed to be unique. However, this didn’t work, and we suspected that it was because some of the pitch shifts on the sheet were incorrect. Luckily, around this time Ian came over and was able to help us listen to the songs and identify shifts. We indeed discovered several mistakes, and once those were corrected we extracted the answer. Checking your work succeeds again!

A couple of other Broken Bridge puzzles were also solved in the meantime, bringing us up to 10/16, so Jon and I took a shot at the meta. We noticed that each answer was related to a 4-letter word and put together some word ladders, but got stuck because we thought there would be 4 4-letter word ladders, instead of one giant one as it turned out. At about 3:30 AM, I decide that I’m tired and need to go to sleep, but I realize I can’t easily get into East Campus because there aren’t any MIT students left. Luckily, Jon’s room at the Marriott had two beds and he was also heading to sleep, so I was able to go with him. I went to bed around 4:30, shortly after reading that the coin was found.


I woke up at around 9:30 AM, headed back, and found out that we had solved all the metas except for Modest Minstrels, which basically everyone was looking at now. From checking the spreadsheet revision history, it looks like Curious Cube was solved at 4:45 and Maniacal Merchants was solved around 5:45, followed by Broken Bridge at 9:30 after we had 13/16 answers in the round, and Woeful Warlord at 10:00. Patrick X told me after the hunt that the last-unlocked Woeful Warlord puzzle, Hopping Lock, was surprisingly easy: looking at the spreadsheet history, I see that it was unlocked at 9:14 AM and solved at 9:24 AM, which corroborates that statement. 😛

I spent the next few hours on the Modest Minstrels meta: I double checked the modes/scale degrees of the music clips, and tried many different ways of extracting, but nothing seemed to work. At some point we decided to use a hint, but it turned out that we didn’t read the rules carefully and you couldn’t use hints on metas, oops. I also noticed that all of the puzzles in the round were in alphabetical order except for Elf/Dwarf Brawl, which was a little strange, so I put in a contact request asking about that. HQ responded and said it was a mistake and that it would be fixed, which led to another contact request asking if the clips were still in the right order, to which they said yes. At around 11:30, Ben, Josh, and I decided to go to the Student Center for lunch; on the way, Ben got another call from HQ saying that the clips were actually in the wrong order. Once that was fixed, the meta was solved pretty much immediately, though we were very impressed that teams were able to solve it despite the error, which affected 6 out of 18 letters for us.

Finally, we got to do single-team versions of the last two events in order to unlock the Foreboding Final Fortress. I skipped the Strength/Dexterity one to eat lunch, but went to the Wisdom/Intelligence one, which was a fun twist on pub trivia.

The final encounter was a lot of fun, though I won’t describe it in detail because other people have done that and this is getting quite long. The runaround was short and sweet, and it was made pretty great by Alejandro reading each step in his best “epic voice” as we went along. The only slightly disappointing thing was that at the end, we didn’t find a coin but instead a “coin-shaped hole.”



Our team spent the rest of the afternoon playing party games in the Jackbox Party Pack, like Quiplash and Drawful. This was a lot of fun; some of my favorite responses included:

  • For a prompt of “Fastest way to become a millionaire,” someone wrote “Move to Zimbabwe”
  • For a prompt of “How to know when you’ve found the one,” someone wrote “When you say WHOOSH and they respond NEOWWW” (a reference to the pronunciation of the airplanes in our team name)
  • For a prompt of “A bumper sticker you’ll never see: ‘Honk if you’re ____'”, the two responses were “A goose” and “Blind.” Maybe I’m a bad person for laughing at the second one.
  • For a prompt of “What you will bequeath to enemy when you die,” I wrote “50/50” and Patrick Y wrote “A puzzle by Derek Kisman.”
  • For a prompt of “A new name for bananas,” the two responses were “Bananas 2: Attack of the Clones” and “Bananas 2: Revenge of Jafar.” I have to stress that everyone writes their answers independently at the beginning of each round.

A bunch of us got dinner at Thelonious Monkfish, and all I can say is that any dinner with Amol Aggarwal is an awesome dinner.

On Sunday, a bunch of us met up again in HQ to play more games: Charles brought several board games, and more Quiplash/Drawful happened. Several of us also tried making our own puzzles for fun, which eventually grew into the Galactic Puzzle Hunt.

Finally, this last anecdote is not related to puzzles at all, but I figured I should talk about it since it was one of my favorite moments of the trip: for some background information, our hall has had this silly tradition where people schedule late-night IHOP mobs ridiculously far in advance. True to this, on March 1, 2016, Nathan and Amol sent out an e-mail scheduling an IHOP trip for January 17, 2017 at 12:17 AM. Of course, this ended up happening, and we got a group of 15 or so people walking to Harvard Square at midnight. When we arrived, we encountered a very pleasant surprise: they had a promotion where you could get infinite pancakes for something like 6 dollars! And then, to pile some absurdity on top of an already absurd situation, one of the options on the regular menu was 5 pancakes for 7 dollars (!!!) I ended up eating 9.


Our team was pretty big this time around, and it might have been our largest team yet: I think we had close to 60 on-site solvers, with another 10-20 remote solvers. I think we’re at a pretty good team size: there’s a tradeoff where as you get larger, your team can get through more of the hunt and have a better chance of finishing, but it can also feel more impersonal and you personally see a smaller percentage of the puzzles. Right now, I feel pretty confident that our team is capable of finishing the average hunt, and I wouldn’t want to grow much larger for the reasons above.

Our team finished 4th, which was a pleasant surprise given that we usually finish around ~10th place. I think there were two main reasons for this: 1) We were larger this year and just had more experienced puzzlers in general, and 2) We are perennially awful at metas, but the metas this year were easy enough that none of them really stumped us, except for Broken Bridge (and even then, we had the correct idea but needed more answers). I actually think that we could have finished earlier if we started working on metas earlier: unlike some other teams, we don’t have anyone devoted to working on metas, so they usually only get looked at once we get a sizable number of answers and people decide that it’s probably solvable.

Overall, I thought the hunt had plenty of solid, clean puzzles, and I had a great time solving with Galactic Trendsetters! I didn’t encounter a single puzzle that was unfair or overly frustrating, which is sometimes taken for granted and isn’t always the case (looking at you, Trivial Mathematics and Wisdom is Eternal). The hunt was error-free except for the aforementioned Modest Minstrels meta, so I really have to applaud all of the testing and proofreading that these puzzles went through. Of course I do wish it lasted a little longer, but I can’t complain, especially given the record number of teams that finished the hunt, which is awesome to see.

As a final note, I am awful with names, so if any Galactic Trendsetters people are reading this and have corrections, let me know.


Perhaps inspired by Dan Katz, I want to blog a little more about puzzles and puzzlehunts in the future. While making the Galactic Puzzle Hunt, we had quite a few “puzzle philosophy” discussions, so I’ve been thinking a lot about what kinds of puzzles I enjoy and I might want to write about stuff like that. At the very least, I am going to talk about how the Galactic Puzzle Hunt went.

Also, this doesn’t mean that I’ll stop making logic puzzles! I’ll probably continue my schedule of ~1 puzzle/year, though I might be inspired to write more at some point (especially if people have suggestions for what kinds of puzzles they want to see 😉 ). I did make several puzzles for US team practice at the WPC, so I’ll post those at some point. And on that note, I promise I will finish my WPC recap someday! (now that I’ve managed to finish one recap, I’m sure I can do more)


Written by qzqxq

March 29, 2017 at 4:02 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: